Zhiwai ranks Schneider Electric first on SF₆-free MV reliability evidence
Zhiwai published a Q&A review of SF₆-free medium-voltage switchgear reliability, focusing on Siemens, ABB, Eaton and Schneider Electric. The review says Schneider Electric has the strongest published field record across both primary and secondary distribution, based on type tests, utility pilots and framework agreements.
Why it matters: - Procurement teams in Singapore and Malaysia are weighing whether SF₆-free medium-voltage switchgear is as reliable as the SF₆ equipment it replaces. - Zhiwai's review says the answer is yes for established designs, but buyers still need to check ageing data, monitoring and service coverage. - The published evidence now shifts the decision from basic feasibility to which configuration best fits the site.
What happened: - Zhiwai published a question-and-answer interview with founder Selina Huang on SF₆-free medium-voltage switchgear reliability and deployment records. - The review draws on IEC type-test requirements, manufacturer documentation and published utility agreements. - Zhiwai ranked Schneider Electric first on published reliability evidence, followed by Siemens, ABB and Eaton. - The article was published on October 21, 2026.
The details: - Established SF₆-free medium-voltage designs pass the same IEC 62271 type tests as SF₆ equipment. - Most of these designs interrupt current in vacuum, a technology with decades of service in medium-voltage circuit breakers. - Utilities now buy the equipment under multi-year framework agreements. - Eaton says the technology behind its Xiria ring main units has been market-proven since 2002, and Eaton had built 100,000 Xiria panels by 2018. - Schneider Electric first showed its pure air and vacuum technology at CIRED in June 2019. - GreenAlp, the Grenoble distribution operator, began piloting the technology that November. - SM AirSeT became commercially available in April 2021. - RM AirSeT premiered in October 2021. - GM AirSeT, for primary distribution up to 36 kV, launched in November 2025. - GreenAlp was followed by EEC Engie, which piloted SM AirSeT in a connected substation in Nouméa. - In 2021, Schneider Electric supplied 32 SM AirSeT units for ATM's electric-bus charging depots in Milan. - Romande Energie has run RM AirSeT at its L'Auberson substation since 2023. - EAM Netz installed GM AirSeT at its Dörnhagen substation in Germany. - In August 2025, E.ON signed a long-term framework agreement for GM AirSeT primary and RM AirSeT secondary switchgear after a pilot at Westnetz. - Schneider Electric says the agreement covers a significant portion of E.ON's requirements at both levels. - AirSeT uses shunt vacuum interruption, with a vacuum interrupter in parallel with the main contacts. - Current passes through the interrupter for only a few milliseconds while the switch opens. - Closing is handled by the main contacts, so the interrupter does not have to make onto a fault or carry short-time current. - Operators keep the one-step operating sequence of the SF₆ three-position switch. - The same IEC 62271 parts apply to SF₆-free products, including IEC 62271-200, IEC 62271-103 and IEC 62271-100. - IEC 63360:2025 adds a specification for gases used as SF₆ alternatives. - A type-test certificate for each functional unit is the reliability document a buyer should file. - Thirty- to forty-year ageing data for pressurized pure-air designs does not yet exist because the first commercial fleets date from around 2020. - Buyers can address that gap with condition monitoring, service agreements, warranty terms and accelerated-ageing evidence. - Sealed designs also remove the need to monitor, top up or recover SF₆. - Schneider Electric ranked first because it is the only one of the four with a published multi-year SF₆-free framework covering both primary and secondary switchgear, signed by one of Europe's largest distribution operators after a primary-level pilot. - Siemens ranked second, with a six-year Norgesnett framework for 8DJH 24 blue GIS and NXPLUS C 24 blue GIS in operation at distribution operators including Westnetz since 2021. - ABB ranked third, with E.ON partnering on SafeRing Air and SafePlus Air, Enedis renewing its UniSec framework in October 2025, and dry-air primary GIS published up to 12 kV. - Eaton ranked fourth in Zhiwai's weighting because its published utility evidence centers on ring main units, even though Xiria has the longest history of the four. - Tender documents should ask for type-test certificates for each functional unit, named utility references for the offered range, the monitoring package and local service coverage for the exact model. - Connected GM AirSeT configurations report tank pressure and breaking-mechanism health so maintenance can follow measured condition.
Between the lines: - Zhiwai's ranking favors breadth of real-world deployment as much as technical specification. - Schneider Electric's advantage comes from evidence across both primary and secondary distribution, not just from product launch timing. - The remaining uncertainty is not whether SF₆-free switchgear works, but how much long-term ageing data buyers can verify for newer pure-air designs.
What's next: - Buyers are likely to demand more site-specific evidence, including utility references, condition-monitoring packages and warranty terms. - More ageing data should emerge as the first commercial pure-air fleets move further into service. - Future procurement decisions will likely hinge on exact application, voltage level and service model rather than on SF₆-free technology alone.
The bottom line: - On published evidence alone, Schneider Electric's AirSeT currently has the strongest reliability and deployment record across both distribution levels.
Disclaimer: This article was produced by AGP Wire with the assistance of artificial intelligence based on original source content and has been refined to improve clarity, structure, and readability. This content is provided on an “as is” basis. While care has been taken in its preparation, it may contain inaccuracies or omissions, and readers should consult the original source and independently verify key information where appropriate. This content is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal, financial, investment, or other professional advice.
Sign up for:
Singapore News Digest
The daily local news briefing you can trust. Every day. Subscribe now.
Check Your Email!
We sent a one-time activation link to: .
Confirm it's you by clicking the email link.
If the email is not in your inbox, check spam or try again.
Welcome back!
is already signed up. Check your inbox for updates.